Fetter's Dairy Isle
This premier ice cream shop in Newark specializes in artisanal frozen desserts, offering a wide range of gourmet flavors that elevate the traditional ice cream experience.
With an emphasis on quality and innovation, the shop sources local ingredients to create unique combinations that cater to discerning palates.
Known for its exceptional customer service and inviting atmosphere, this establishment not only satisfies sweet cravings but also serves as a community hub for enthusiasts of all ages. The shop's commitment to excellence and creativity ensures that every visit is a memorable one, making it a top destination for both casual visitors and ice cream connoisseurs alike.
Latest Feedback
- "The variety of flavors here is impressive! Each scoop tastes fresh and unique, making every visit an exciting adventure for the taste buds."
"I was blown away by the quality of the ingredients used. This place truly elevates ice cream to an art form, and the staff is always friendly."
"A fantastic spot for families and friends! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the creative flavors make it a go-to for dessert lovers."
Customer Reviews
What People Say
Micah Yoshida
April 2, 2025
I stopped by this local ice cream shop after hearing great things from friends, and I have to say, it lived up to the hype! The atmosphere is cozy, and the staff made me feel right at home. I indulged in a scoop of their strawberry cheesecake flavor, and it was heavenly—light and creamy with chunks of real cheesecake mixed in. My only wish is that they would offer more toppings, as I love piling on the goodies! The wait time was a bit longer than expected, but it was worth it for such a tasty treat. I can see myself coming here regularly, especially on warm summer nights. Can't wait to explore more flavors!
Genesis Silverstone
October 24, 2024
This place is a total gem! The ice cream is delicious, and the prices are reasonable. I had the mint chocolate chip, and it was so refreshing. Definitely going to return!
Astrid Brooks
August 15, 2024
I recently visited this charming little ice cream shop and wow, I was blown away! The selection is fantastic - from classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique twists like lavender honey. I tried the salted caramel and it was simply divine, creamy and rich with just the right amount of salt. The staff was incredibly friendly and helped me navigate through their extensive menu. They even let me sample a few flavors before making my decision! I also loved the outdoor seating area; it was a perfect spot to enjoy my ice cream on a warm afternoon. My only small complaint is that their parking lot can get quite crowded, especially during peak hours, but that's a testament to how popular this place is. I can’t wait to go back and try their seasonal flavors next time. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth looking for a delightful treat!
Natasha MacDonald
November 17, 2023
Just had an amazing sundae here! The hot fudge was rich, and the whipped cream was fresh and fluffy. Perfect dessert spot for a hot day. Will definitely return!
Jessica Wilson
April 6, 2022
Absolutely loved my experience here! The variety of flavors is out of this world – I tried the orange creamsicle, and it took me back to my childhood. It was not too sweet, just the right balance! The staff was super friendly and made recommendations that hit the mark perfectly. I also appreciated that they have some dairy-free options, which is a huge plus for those with dietary restrictions. The only thing I would suggest is to have a few more tables available for busy nights, as it can get pretty packed. But overall, a fantastic spot for ice cream lovers. I’m already planning my next visit!
Today
Opening Hours
| Monday | 11 am–9 pm |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11 am–9 pm |
| Wednesday | 11 am–9 pm |
| Thursday | 11 am–9 pm |
| Friday | 11 am–9 pm |
| Saturday | 11 am–9 pm |
| Sunday | 11 am–9 pm |
How to go there
Location
Ice cream shop Loc: 40.0573 / -82.4216
Plan your visit
Weather
- Newark
| Temperature | N/A °F | |
|---|---|---|
| feels like | N/A °F |